How to ask for a testimonial (and get great testimonials that sell)

Where & how to use testimonials on your website

You have great testimonials. But when was the last time they actually helped you make a sale?

If they’re sitting on a sales page that gets 10 visitors a month, or buried on a page nobody clicks, they’re not doing their job. Testimonials can be one of your strongest assets for building trust and improving your conversion rate. You don’t need dozens of them to make an impact. A few strong ones in the right places can make a real difference.

Most course creators I work with have plenty of social proof. The problem usually isn’t the quality (though we’ll talk about that). More often, testimonials aren’t being seen, aren’t structured to convert, or aren’t being used beyond the sales page.

In this post, I’ll show you how to ask for a testimonial in a way that gives you something actually usable, where to put testimonials so they get seen, and how to build a simple system so your social proof keeps working without you having to think about it.

What makes a testimonial actually work

There’s a big difference between a testimonial that makes someone feel warm and fuzzy and one that makes them reach for their credit card.

Here’s one that doesn’t work so well:

“Anouska is great! Highly recommend.”

Nice. But it doesn’t tell us what problem was solved, how the client felt before, or what changed after. A potential client reading this thinks: OK, but is this relevant to me?

Compare that to this one:

I was getting overwhelmed with all the tasks for my online course. Working with Anouska has massively eased my stress levels! I’m now able to focus on what I love, coaching and teaching, which has transformed my business and my life. She’s set up platforms and systems that work by themselves, saving invaluable time and energy. Thanks to Anouska, I’ve now had several smooth and successful course launches!
– Rebecca Tolin

That works because it has three clear components:

The before: “I was getting overwhelmed with all the tasks for my online course.”

The how: “She’s set up platforms and systems that work by themselves, saving invaluable time and energy.”

The after: “I’m now able to focus on what I love… I’ve now had several smooth and successful course launches!”

When potential clients read this, they see themselves in the “before” and want the “after.” That’s what a good testimonial does.

How to ask for a testimonial (so you get something useful)

You ask a client for a testimonial. They say “sure, happy to!” And then… nothing. Three weeks later you’re still waiting, and it feels too awkward to chase.

They want to help. But you’ve handed them a blank page, and they don’t know what to say. Or they write something like “She did a great job. Highly recommend.” Lovely to get, useless on your sales page.

Ask for feedback, not a testimonial

Instead of asking for a testimonial, ask them to fill in a short feedback form. Then write the testimonial yourself, using their words, and send it to them to approve.

To be clear, you’re not writing fake reviews. You’re not making anything up. You take the words they gave you, tidy them up, and ask for approval. They can edit it, rewrite it, or say no.

Set up your feedback form

Build it in whatever you already use: Google Forms, Tally, Typeform, Airtable.

Ask at 2 moments:

  • At signup: questions 1 to 3, in an onboarding form when someone starts working with you, or at the start of your course or group program.
  • At the end: questions 4 to 10, on a feedback form when they finish, or when they’ve seen a result.

Set it up this way for everyone new. For people who’ve already finished, ask all 10 at the end. You still need the signup answers for the best testimonials.

Testimonial questions to ask at signup

1. What were you struggling with before you signed up? This gives you the “before.” Your reader is looking for someone who was where they are now. They need to recognise themselves in it to trust that your offer can help them.

2. What was the thing that finally made you sign up? There’s almost always a specific moment that got them to take action. The answer helps you write the testimonial, and it can make the rest of your marketing better too, by talking about those moments.

3. Did you have any hesitations before signing up? Whatever your client was worried about, other people are worried about the same thing. Once you know it, you can handle that objection on your sales page and in your marketing.

Testimonial questions to ask at the end

4. What specifically changed, and how long did it take? This gets you the “after,” plus a timeframe, which answers the question every buyer has: how long until I see results?

5. Which part made the biggest difference? If they can name a specific part of your course or program, the reader has something specific to want, and it sets you apart from the others they’re looking at.

6. Was it what you expected? If anything was different, better or worse, what was it? If expectations were different, you can adjust your sales page so the next person knows what they’re getting.

7. What would you say to someone thinking about doing this? The words people use when they recommend something to a specific person are much more persuasive than a generic endorsement.

8. Was there anything that could have been better, or anything you’d change? Yes, really. Most of the time you’ll get “nothing, it was great.” Sometimes you’ll get something small and fixable, and your offer gets better for the next person.

9. Anything else you’d like to add? (optional) Some people want to write something themselves. Let them. Make it optional so it doesn’t slow anyone else down.

10. Would it be OK to use parts of your answers as a testimonial?

  • Yes, with my full name
  • Yes, with my first name only
  • Yes, but please keep me anonymous
  • No, please keep this private

Get this permission in writing at the same time as the feedback, so you’re never guessing what you’re allowed to publish.

If you work in a niche where people don’t want to put their name to it, you can still have useful testimonials. Your reader needs enough to picture a specific person: job, age, location, how long they’d had the problem, whether they have kids. “S., 34, 2 kids under 5” does the job, sometimes better than a name, because the next 34-year-old with small children reads it and thinks that’s me.

The email to send the form with

Send it while you’re still fresh in their mind: right at the end of the project, or just after they’ve seen a result. That’s when they’re most enthusiastic and most specific. Three months later, the details have faded.

Subject: How did it go?

Hi [name],

You’ve reached the end of [program]. Thank you for being part of it.

I’d love to know what worked for you and what I could do better next time.

If you’d feel comfortable, would you be willing to spend 10 minutes answering a few questions? [link]

Short answers are fine, and skip anything that doesn’t apply.

Thank you, I really appreciate it.

[your name]

The email asks for feedback rather than a testimonial, which takes the pressure off. Nobody has to decide whether they liked it enough to say something nice in public.

No reply after a week? Send one short, friendly nudge:

Just floating this back to the top of your inbox in case it got buried. No pressure at all if now’s not a good time.

Don’t want to remember to do this every single time? That’s what I set up in the Social Proof System Setup: the feedback form goes out automatically when a project ends, and every answer lands in one organised place instead of scattered across your inbox.

How to draft the testimonial from their answers

What comes back is usually a bit messy. That’s fine, it’s raw material. Cut it down to what a stranger needs:

Before (from the signup form) → process (what it was like) → after (what changed).

Before and after do most of the work. Your reader is trying to work out whether this applies to them, and the only way they can tell is by comparing where this person started against their own situation. The process part should answer something a buyer might worry about: how much time it takes, whether they can keep up, whether it’s easy to follow.

Here’s a made-up example.

What came back:

What were you struggling with: I’m tired all the time. I’ve tried every supplement I was recommended but I’m still tired all the time.

Any hesitations: I’d been reading about this stuff for two years and getting nowhere, so I assumed this would be more of the same. But you were the first person who explained why it happens instead of just handing me a meal plan, so I gave it a go.

What changed: I’m up before my alarm most days. Not every day, but most. And I’ve stopped having the 4pm crash where I’d need something sweet just to make it to dinner.

Biggest difference: The breakfast swap. I’d had the same thing every morning for years and never really thought about it.

Highlight the specific phrases, put them in order, and join them up with as few of your own words as possible.

The drafted testimonial:

“I tried every supplement I was recommended, but I was still tired all the time. I’d been reading about this for 2 years and getting nowhere. It was the first time anyone explained why it happens instead of just handing me a meal plan. The breakfast swap made the biggest difference. Now I’m up before my alarm most mornings, and the 4pm crash where I’d need something sweet just to get through to dinner is gone.”

Nothing in it they didn’t say. It’s tidied and ordered so the before, the process, and the after are all in there.

The approval email

Send it back and let them have the final say. Add their original answers so they can see where every phrase came from.

Subject: Would it be OK to use this?

Hi [name],

Thank you for your answers. Would it be OK to use this as a testimonial?

[the testimonial you drafted]

These were your original answers:

What were you struggling with before you signed up? [their answer]

Did you have any hesitations before signing up? [their answer]

Which part made the biggest difference? [their answer]

Thank you, [your name]

Almost everyone replies “yes, perfect.” Occasionally someone tweaks a word. Very occasionally someone says no, and you thank them anyway and move on.

Want all of this ready to go? The free Testimonial Request Toolkit has every question, the request and approval emails, and a worksheet for turning messy answers into a testimonial you can use, plus how to go back to past clients and students who finished months ago and never got asked.

What if the feedback isn’t all positive?

Well done for asking, because now you know something you didn’t before. Reply as a person, not a business, and thank them properly. If something went wrong and you can fix it, fix it. If it’s a mismatch of expectations, that’s usually a sign to make your sales page or onboarding clearer.

You don’t publish that part, but don’t ignore it either. Keep a note of it and use it to improve your offer. And don’t let one piece of criticism undo all the good stuff.

What if you don’t have any clients yet?

  • Run a small beta version of your offer at a reduced price, or free, in exchange for feedback and a testimonial, using these same questions.
  • Ask a former manager, colleague, or collaborator to speak to how you work: reliability, communication, how you handled a tricky project.
  • Ask for feedback on unpaid or volunteer work, or a project for a friend.
  • If you’ve helped anyone and it worked, even for free, ask them.

Where to put testimonials on your website

A separate testimonials page gets very little traffic on its own, and most visitors never find it. It’s much more effective to sprinkle testimonials throughout your site, with the heaviest concentration on your sales pages.

Anywhere someone might hesitate, a relevant testimonial helps. That includes:

  • Your homepage (especially near your main call to action)
  • Your About page (helps build trust early)
  • Your opt-in landing pages (if you have testimonials for your free resource)
  • Product pages if you’re selling digital products

It’s completely fine to use the same testimonial in multiple places. If a testimonial is relevant to your course and your services, use it on both pages.

One formatting note: don’t use sliders or carousels for testimonials. Heatmaps consistently show that most visitors don’t click through, so a big chunk of your social proof stays invisible. Show them all directly on the page.

Why your sales page isn’t enough

A sales page doesn’t get traffic if nobody’s driving people to it. Which is what emails and social posts do.

If your testimonials only live on your website, they’re doing very little of the work they could be doing. Strong testimonials work best when people encounter them repeatedly, in different contexts, not only at the exact moment they’re ready to buy.

This is the part most people skip: testimonials aren’t just a website element. They are marketing content. The same before-and-after structure that works on a sales page works just as well in an email, a social post, or a launch sequence.

How to use testimonials in your marketing (beyond your website)

Once you have strong testimonials collected, here’s how to put them to work:

In emails: Share a client’s before-and-after in your regular email. No pitch required, just share the transformation and link to your sales page at the end. Subscribers who’ve seen the same result described three or four times in different emails are far more likely to trust that it’s real.

In social posts: Turn a testimonial into a quote graphic, or share a screenshot of a client message with a caption explaining what made their result possible.

In launch content: Feature a different client story each day of a launch sequence. Let their words do the selling.

As content ideas: If a client says “I finally stopped second-guessing my pricing,” that’s a content topic. Write about it, and use their testimonial as proof the shift is possible.

The best part: you’re not starting from scratch. You’re sharing what you already have.

The part that most people never get around to: making it a system

Asking for testimonials, collecting them somewhere useful, and actually using them in your marketing all sounds simple. And it is, once it’s set up. The problem is that most course creators are collecting testimonials in three different places (email, DMs, a Google Doc from years ago), forgetting to ask half the time, and then spending 20 minutes searching for the right one when they need it.

If you want your social proof to actually do something, it needs a home. That means:

  • A simple, automatic way to collect testimonials after each client project or course completion
  • One central place where everything lives, organised so you can find the right testimonial in 30 seconds
  • A format that makes it easy to find testimonials for emails, sales pages, and social content without having to hunt

This is exactly what I set up in the Social Proof System Setup. I’ll organise everything you already have and build the collection and management system, so new testimonials come in automatically, and you always know where to find them.

If promoting your course feels harder than it should, it’s often because the social proof you already have isn’t working for you yet.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Evergreen Funnel Fix

If you stopped posting tomorrow, would your course still sell?

For most course creators the answer is no. Write down your last 10 students and you'll usually find the same thing: every one of them arrived because of something you personally did. A post, a launch, a conversation, a DM.

The Evergreen Funnel Fix is a free guide built around that exercise. 15 minutes, 2 columns, and a clear read on which of your students found you on their own, and what to fix so more of them can.

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top